For a leather gift, look for full-grain leather and clear construction details,...

https://mike-wiki.win/index.php/Which_Brand_Should_I_Pick_If_I_Want_Initials_but_Hate_Shiny_Foil%3F

For a leather gift, look for full-grain leather and clear construction details, not just polished photos. Read the warranty before buying, and check how initials are applied - stamped, embossed, or printed - so the personalization suits him.